Normally I don't go around throwing my opinion at people, but am really sick of the old "option one is good, option two is bad" choice system. No human being (except many Jesus) has ever been pure good! No human being in history is pure bad! Nor do we act super evil one minute and good the next! Good and bad are boring!
You have the perfect opportunity to think outside the box! Here is my advice, have an Orange and Blue morality system. Rather than let people be good or bad, let people decide where they stand in unique places.
Imagine a boulder rolls into a river due to nature, and two people see it happen. Person one wants to move the boulder because it is in the way of the water flow and is causing the water to move around the boulder. Because the water flow is different, he thinks it might cause harm to the land beyond where the water flows. Person two wants to not touch the boulder because nature is the reason the boulder got there in the first place, therefore moving the boulder would be interfering with nature. In this situation, neither person is right or wrong, yet you might feel inclined to side with one of them. Isn't that more thought provoking than "Should I kill the puppy or give it a bowl of water?"