I can't help feeling that us telling you to make a game with a a certain style is really quite pointless. YOU should know your capabilities, and YOU should know how you want your game to play... If you do not, then noone here can help you, and getting a list of people saying "I like blah..." is no use unless they can apply "blah" to YOUR specific game.
If your topic even went into depth about the actual gameplay you want to have and explained why you
think each graphic style could be good and why it could be bad, then I'd understand, as you are offering discussion material to the people on the forum. However, as it stands, you offer nothing and ask people to make a judgement based on that... which seems pretty pointless. So, please add into your topic some information about your game so that we can give an INFORMED opinion, and maybe outline your thoughts on each possible style and why you think it is good or bad.