Say, we have a multiplayer Quake-like FPS with true-3D environments (ie multiple floors) and maybe even jumping. What suits it the best - full mouselook, just your plain Doom-like control scheme with slight autoaiming along the vertical axis, or manual vertical aiming using the keyboard?
I know what you'll answer, but it's nice IMO to have an FPS with teh good ol' keyboard controls to spice up things a bit.
Control scheme sample for teh second one:
A S D LT DN RT
W jumps, S shoots, A & D strafe left/right
Arrows control moving fwd/bwd and turning around.